Originally Posted by
Kevin
Wellllll,
Not so much.
I love my country but there is nothing truly exceptional about our system of government. Plenty of other countries have much more functional systems, depending on your criteria for success. The Finns, the Swedes, the Norwegians, the Danes, the Belgians, the Czechs, the Slovakians, the Austrians, the Monacans, lots of countries could make a serious case for having a more functional system of government. That's just one continent and only the more representational forms of government.
The principles of our founding were wonderful and noble. In practice, things got messy. We tolerated slavery in our foundational document, killed each other over that issue in a big civil war, were just fine with genocide against our own Native Americans; we institutionalized racism and bigotry. We have always opposed immigration from any "non-Western" sources and at one time, included Southern and Eastern Europeans as criminals or subhuman. We didn't let Catholics have jobs. Our own government agencies, in the late 20th century, were taken to court for pervasive bias against black farmers and won by showing incontrovertible evidence of discrimination.
We have sponsored assassinations. We have sponsored coups. We support dictators. We talk about human rights and morals and at the same time prop up the Shah of Iran. Or Hussein. Or Pinochet. Or Marcos. Or Botha. Or Ortega, until he became inconvenient. There is A LOT of misery in this world, especially in the developing nations, that we directly caused.
I think it is time to give up the idea of American Exceptionalism. I love my country, warts and all, but I see the warts and want us to do better.